8 Best Shaving Soaps for Sensitive Skin

Even if you have the best manscaping tools on hand, shaving can be a daunting task if you have sensitive skin. That’s why you’ll need the best shaving soaps for sensitive skin by your side. Like shaving cream, shaving soaps can help you shave faster and more efficiently. And they usually use gentle formulas, making them safe to use for all skin types. 

For this post, I perused 50+ shaving soaps exclusive for sensitive to pick the eight you must consider. See which one suits your unique shaving needs the best.

SHAVING SOAPBRANDEXPERT RATINGCHECK PRICE
 Our Top Pick! 
Proraso Shaving Soap
Check Price
Arko Shaving Soap Check Price
Col. Conk Shaving Soap Check Price
Taylor of Old Bond Street Shaving Soap Check Price
Van Der Hagen Shaving Soap Check Price
Williams Mug Shaving Soap Check Price
Bull and Bell Shaving Soap Check Price
Shaving Soap by Essentially Organic Soap Check Price

Do I Really Need to Use Shaving Soap?

Like most beard products, shaving soaps are optional, but each one has unique benefits. For instance, combining your preferred shaving tool with quality soap yields better results. It lubricates the grooming tool, helping it glide better, protecting your skin. 

If you’re still unsure, here are more reasons why you should add shaving soap to your shaving routine from now on:

  • Achieve cleaner cuts. Shaving soap removes oil on your face, letting water penetrate your face better. And this softens your stubble or beard better, resulting in a cleaner cut. 
  • Experience increased hydration. To prevent bumps and cuts when shaving, shaving soap helps increase hydration. It does this by creating a larger and deeper lather. 
  • It saves you money. Although shaving soaps cost more than other beard products, they often last longer. So you’ll be saving more money in the long run. 
  • Shave responsibly. Shaving soaps are usually made with natural or organic ingredients. And since they’re not like traditional shaving creams, which contain lots of chemicals, they’re more sustainable. 

If you’re struggling to shave due to your sensitive skin, the eight shaving soaps below will help you achieve a cleaner, safer, and comfortable cut every time. 


Best Shaving Soaps for Sensitive Skin – Our Top 8!

OUR #1 CHOICE

OUR TOP PICK: Proraso Shaving Soap

Product Name: Proraso Shaving Soap

Product Description: If you're looking for the best shaving soap for men with sensitive skin, look no further than Proraso Shaving Soap. This product contains menthol and eucalyptus for better cuts and reduced skin irritation. Plus, this unique blend stimulates your face better, opening your pores while softening your hair and skin in the process. With this, you can be confident of getting the closest shave possible without harming your skin. Moreover, it follows traditional hot processing, making it denser for lasting use. Overall, this shaving soap by Proraso gives you the best value for your money. Invest in Proraso to get cleaner cuts without damaging your skin—and bank account!

Offer price: $$$

Availability: InStock

  • Ingredients
  • Design
  • Value for money
  • Efficiency
Overall
5

Summary

Due to its rich benefits and reasonable price, Proraso has become one of the most popular shaving soap brands for men with sensitive skin—including me! In addition, its use of traditional hot processing gives you a richer and thicker lather for added skin protection. With this, you’ll get cleaner cuts without worry, keeping skin irritation at bay.

However, some buyers complain about the product not having a slick enough surface for thick beards. But overall, if you’re looking for an affordable pick without sacrificing efficiency and quality, Proraso Shaving Soap is your best bet.

Pros

  • Soothes skin
  • Creates thick and deep lather
  • Has a generous portion size
  • Guarantees close shave 
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Some buyers complain about the product not having a slick surface for thicker beards.

RUNNERS-UP

Arko Shaving Soap

If you’re looking for a shaving soap that can go with you anywhere at any time, consider Arko Shaving Soap. This is a stick shaving soap made for busy men on the go. It helps make shaving sessions on the road more bearable, comfortable—and convenient.

This men’s grooming brand has been around for years, and for good reasons. It uses a unique formula different than conventional shaving soaps. As a result, you get a flexible product that you can adjust into smaller pieces when needed.

However, though you can prepare it in a mug or bowl, I like using it as it is. After all, it’s conveniently designed as a stick for direct and easy application. All you must do is apply and gently rub it on your face and lather it using a brush.

But what stands out about this shaving soap is that it produces generous amounts of lather despite its size. And a great thing about Arko is that you can buy dozens of sticks for the price of one container from modern brands.

Overall, this product is ideal for traveling men on the go, giving clean cuts and close finishes anywhere at any time. And, really, you’re getting the most value for your money with this shaving soap.

However, like most products, it also has its downsides. Although its efficiency is unbeatable, its scent isn’t the best. Many buyers have complained about it having a chemical-like scent.

Anyway, you can just cover it up with an aftershave.

Pros
  • Flexible formula
  • Provides generous lather for easy shaving
  • Has a compact design
  • Can be used as ease
  • Affordable
Cons
  • It has a chemical-like scent. Anyway, you can cover it up with an aftershave.

Col Conk Shaving Soap

Col. Conk Shaving Soap is proudly made in the USA, promising excellent quality and value for money. It’s one of the longest-standing and well-known brands in the industry, offering vast options of fragrances.

But what makes this shaving soap stand out is its use of glycerin. This chemical helps in producing generous amounts of lather without effort. And the best part is, it isn’t as harmful as other ingredients used to create foam like sulfate.

As a result, this product is safe to use for all skin types.

Aside from that, this product is available in different scents and fragrances. However, the most common and popular variation favored by barbers is Bay Rum. And seeing how long Col. Conk has been around, it seems most men also agree.

Its unique bay rum scent isn’t overpowering and lasts for a long time. So you can use your favorite aftershave without worry!

Moreover, this product is also one of the most flexible. After all, the company manufactured this with hard water in mind. Therefore, it can lather well regardless of the water conditions you’re experiencing.

But what I really like the most about this shaving soap is that it’s budget-friendly. So you can confidently shave your face without breaking the bank!

The only issue is that this shaving soap dries out fast since it’s mostly made up of glycerin. Anyway, if this becomes a recurring issue, you can just use more of the soap.

Pros
  • Glycerin-based
  • Produces thick and deep lather
  • Formulated to lather on all water conditions
  • Has a unique and subtle scent
  • Affordable
Cons
  • Dries out quickly.
  • Small portion size.

Taylor of Old Bond Street Shaving Soap

Are you looking for an extra foamy yet gentle shaving soap to protect your skin when shaving? Consider Taylor of Old Bond Street Shaving Soap.

This unique shaving soap uses a unique Sandalwood formula for extra lather. And though it’s shaving soap, it’s made of soft cream, which you can apply with different kinds of razors. Whether it’s a double-edged or razor, this product has got it covered.

Aside from that, this brand markets a vast collection of scents and ingredients. So if Sandalwood doesn’t cut it for you, you can always check Taylor of Old Bond Street for other options.

But, many men, including me, vouch for this shaving soap’s masculine yet subtle scent.

However, what I love about this product is its gentle blend. It produces a creamy and fluffy lather for better cuts and close shaves. Moreover, since it sticks nicely to razors, it can protect your face whenever you shave. As a result, men of all skin types can use this without worry.

But even though it has a subtle and refreshing scent, many still complain about its unusual fragrance. After all, even if it is subtle, it can still linger on your face for hours on end.

Fortunately, using aftershave can easily block off the shaving soap’s smell.

Pros
  • Produces smooth and creamy lather
  • Uses a gentle formula
  • Suitable for all skin types
  • Moisturizes face
  • Packed in an ergonomic bowl design
Cons
  • Some buyers complain of its overpowering scent.
  • A little pricy.

Van Der Hagen Shaving Soap

If you’re suffering from dryness in addition to your sensitive skin, the Van Der Hagen Shaving Soap is your best bet. It’s a hypo-allergenic shaving soap that packs extra hydrating properties. As a result, you get healthier and smoother skin alongside a cleaner cut.

Also, it lathers up very well, thanks to its glycerin content. With this, you get to experience a luxurious shave without overspending at home.

Aside from that, its unique blend of cocoa butter and mango give it an extra hydrating punch. So after each shave, you’ll notice your skin feeling smoother than ever. And to make this soap even better, it comes with a subtle yet masculine scent.

It uses a light scent of bay rum and sandalwood, helping you smell better after each shave. And the best part is, it isn’t too overpowering, keeping skin irritation at bay.

In addition, you get luxury treatment minus the expensive price tag. So, you’re getting your money’s worth with Van Der Hagen.

Overall, this shaving soap is ideal for men with dry and sensitive skin, thanks to its extra powerful hydrating properties. Each pack contains three bars of Van Der Hagen Shaving Soap.

The only complaint that buyers have with this product is that it runs out too quickly. Anyway, you can avoid this by placing it in a dry and cool place.

Pros
  • Pack of 3
  • Very affordable
  • Lathers well
  • Moisturizes skin after each shave
  • 3-month money guarantee
Cons
  • It melts quickly.

Williams Mug Shaving Soap

For longer-lasting results, pick Williams Mug Shaving Soap. This men’s grooming brand has been in the industry for a while, thanks to its quality products. And this soap is no exception.

This shaving soap produces a generous amount of long-lasting foam without much effort. Moreover, thanks to its unique formula, it lathers pretty well on any shaving tool. As a result, you get better lubrication with each shave, preventing skin irritation.

But, since this aims to produce more lather for your convenience, it doesn’t have the best scent. Its fragrance is neutral, and it smells like your regular soap. So if you don’t mind smelling like soap after each shave, this product is a great pick.

Aside from that, this brand is among the cheapest yet effective in the market. So not only are you getting cleaner cuts, but you’re saving money in the long run as well.

Overall, Williams Mug Shaving Soap is the throwback soap every man needs. From cleaner cuts to closer finishes, this shaving soap has got your back minus the effort!

But a common issue that buyers bring up about this shaving soap is that it doesn’t moisturize well. After all, it is an older brand, and the manufacturers mostly focused on producing lather.

However, it still works pretty well with men with stubbles and average-growing beards. On the other hand, men experiencing heavy beard growth should consider other brands.

Pros
  • Produces generous amounts of lather
  • Lathers to shaving tools well
  • Uses a gentle formula
  • Ideal for all skin types
  • Very affordable
Cons
  • Doesn’t moisturize well.
  • Scent isn’t appealing.
  • Doesn’t work well on heavy beard growth.

Bull and Bell Shaving Soap

The Bull and Bell Shaving Soap is luxury, efficiency, and value all in one package. This is a handmade soap designed and created by American artisans.

It uses a soothing mix of warm amber and sandalwood, providing gentle lather. In addition, this blend gives the soap a soothing scent that’s not too overpowering. For this reason, it’s become a go-to product suitable for all skin types.

As an added precaution, the soap also contains mango butter. This unique ingredient makes its formula safer to use for men with sensitive skin. Plus, the butter also helps in pampering dry skin, hydrating it after each shaving session!

Moreover, it’s rich in texture and smells fantastic.

Overall, if you’re looking for something more luxurious for your sensitive skin, consider Bull and Bell. Each bowl contains 4 ounces of shaving soap, creating a thick cushion for an improved shaving experience.

The only issue is that since it primarily uses quality ingredients, it’s a bit pricier than other brands. Also, it has a generally smaller portion size. But if you don’t mind splurging, this shaving soap makes for an excellent investment.

Pros
  • Uses amber and sandalwood for rich and soothing lather
  • Made from quality ingredients
  • Provides better lubrication
  • Moisturizes skin
  • Has a pleasing and subtle scent
Cons
  • Very expensive.
  • Portion size is small.

Shaving Soap by Essentially Organic Soap

Finally, the last product I recommend for the best shaving soaps for sensitive skin is Shaving Soap by Essentially Organic Soap. This product is an all-natural shaving soap made from botanically-based ingredients. For this reason, it’s ideal for any skin type.

All elements on this soap are free of toxins and all-natural, so you can enjoy nature while enjoying a new and better shaving experience.

It uses a unique combination of palm and sunflower oil alongside charcoal. With this, you can moisturize and nourish your skin after each shave. And this blend of herbs provides healing properties, rescuing your skin over time.

Additionally, the use of charcoal shea butter makes the soap flexible and gentler. As a result, even men with the most delicate skins or severe skin conditions can use this soap without worry.

Overall, if you’re a fan of natural products or want a muskier scent, this shaving soap is for you.

The only complaint about this product is that’s it’s pricy. However, this is quite understandable since it is 100% organic. And not to mention, all soaps are handmade by artisans throughout the USA.

Anyway, the product also covers an order refund, so you can get your money’s worth. Regardless, if you don’t mind splurging for cleaner cuts, closer finishes, and healthier skin, choose Essentially Organic Soap.

Pros
  • Unscented
  • Handmade
  • GMO-free
  • Vegan
  • Uses 100% organic ingredients
Cons
  • Expensive.

Factors to Consider When Choosing the Best Shaving Soaps for Sensitive Skin

There are numerous shaving soaps for men in the market. However, not all are suitable for sensitive skin. To help you find the best option for your unique needs, I listed some factors you must consider. Check them out below!

👨 Skin Sensitivity

Firstly, you need to determine how sensitive your face’s skin is. From there, you need to check the list of ingredients of each shaving soap. And what you need to watch out for is if the product contains irritants. These include ingredients like menthol or clove oil. 

On the other hand, if you have very sensitive skin, it’s best to opt for 100% natural ingredients. After all, even mild irritants like cinnamon can cause severe reactions to people with extremely sensitive skin. 

But generally, products without harmful chemicals are safe to use for all skin types. 

🧼 Type of Shaving Soap

Like other beard products, shaving soaps come in all shapes and sizes. Some of them come in a convenient bowl, stick, or on their own as refills. Here’s a more in-depth insight on each one:

  • Shaving soaps in bowls. This is the most popular type of shaving soap as it’s aesthetically pleasing. Also, not to mention, it’s compact and can fit any bathroom counter, cabinet, or drawer. 
  • Stick shaving soaps. For busy men who are always on their feet, shaving soap sticks are usually the best choice. These are smaller and use water-tight lids, keeping them secure anywhere you go. 
  • Refills. If you already have a bowl, save some money and buy refills instead. Most brands offer exclusive refills for their products. 

📖 Ingredients

Although this is subjective since each user has a unique skin type, checking out the ingredients before buying shaving soaps is ideal. So, how would you know what’s best for you?

Generally, those with dry skin would benefit the most from oil-based soaps. These combine essential oils and moisturizing properties, reducing the dryness on your skin. 

Meanwhile, if you have skin issues like redness or swelling, look for shaving soaps with aloe vera. It’s rich in anti-inflammatory properties, soothing your skin in the process. 

👃 Fragrance

Although there’s nothing wrong with having a little scent in your shaving soap, this can cause skin irritations. This is especially the case if the product uses essential oils for added fragrance. So if you want to prevent breakouts, itchiness, etc., choose unscented soaps.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is using a shaving soap good for, exactly?

A: Using shaving soap when shaving helps water penetrate your face better. With this, it softens and lifts your facial hair for a cleaner and comfortable shave. Also, these provide extra lubrication and protection for your skin. That’s why shaving soaps often leave your skin feeling smoother and healthier than ever. 

Q: Can I use regular soap for shaving?

A: Using regular soap when shaving isn’t a good idea as it can leave your skin drier than before. That’s because these soaps don’t have the proper ingredients to produce stable lather. Moreover, they don’t have the properties ideal for shaving tools, which can lead to rust—fast. 

Q: What’s the difference between regular soap and shaving soap?

A: Shaving soaps have higher potassium and sodium content that’s rich in fat/oil. After all, they need to produce a thicker, deeper, and stable lather to lubricate shaving tools. And it also helps soften facial hair for a cleaner and bump-free cut. 

Q: Which is better for sensitive skin? Shaving cream or shaving soap?

A: Shaving cream has a lighter consistency than shaving soap. Hence, it doesn’t create a stable lather that can moisturize your face in the process. And this can lead to irritation fast, especially if you have sensitive skin. So, if you want to avoid redness, swelling, and scratches, go for shaving soaps. 


Final Words

The best shaving soaps for sensitive skin will help you get cleaner cuts with a closer finish. So besides buying clippers, razors, and other shaving tools, invest in quality shaving soap to get the best results every time!

Are you looking to explore a new style? Here are different beard styles ideal for mature men!